Glaswegian accents affect success of winning jobs

 I read the following press release yesterday: this was describing the results of a survey on accents and employability.
http://www.responsesource.com/releases/rel_display.php?relid=6525

As we all know, discussing accents is an emotive subject for many people. An accent does identify where the speaker is from and class - which for many British people is key. But certain accents provoke prejudice, which I believe could be the cause of the results. My views on accents and where I rank them are different to these results, as I am sure readers would also agree. If I'm analysing the results, I might suggest that there was regional (southern) bias in the research: I doubt if anyone from the north would consider an Essex accent the most preferable accent to have.

 However, the whole issue of accents is interesting when considering 'employability'. In fact a number of well known presenters have said that their middle class accents was a disadvantage when working at the BBC where regional accents are now favoured. To a certain extent, it is 'horses for courses'; a Public School accent for a business with many people of that background would be an advantage, but wouldn't work so well, if they were targeting Liverpool clients. Yet the lovely Ashley in Michel Roux's "Service" demonstrated that he didn't need to speak RP to engage some very posh guests at a country hotel: his warm, endearing personality was a winning formula.

When I first taught in London, the headmistress of the prep school I was working at was incredibly posh. However, upon meeting her family, it transpired that they didn't present themselves in that way, and she had consciously 'lost' her scouse accent between Liverpool and Euston station, to advance her career. Another headmistress I have met: a dynamic, successful primary head, was told to 'get rid of her brummie accent if she wanted to get on' - and this was in Essex.

In the end, it is about being understood; speaking clearly, effectively and appropriately. A thick accent whether it be Public School posh; Glaswegian or Scouse is more difficult to understand than a voice with 'a little' accent, which still provides interest and individuality. However, poor grammar - of the Louise Rednapp/Alesha Dixon "You was great" variety, does not give a good impression; rather it shows the person is lazy and poorly educated. Would I employ them - or even buy from them: no. Would I employ or buy from someone who has a Glaswegian accent - yes, if they spoke clearly, with good grammar!

Are you less employable if you have a strong accent?

At the weekend I read an article about a gentleman that was not employed for a particular job. On asking for feedback from his interviewers, they revealed that his accent was one reason why he wasn't selected.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1353606/Shemi-Leira-turned-job-African-accent-rich-customers.html

This area is always of interest to me. Accents provoke emotion in everyone; certain accents make you feel negative about them, others positive. It could be based on expectation or whether or not you can understand them easily.

On two separate occasions Executive Voice have provided training for individuals and teams, where one of the issues was 'accents'. In the first, a highly qualified and valued professional received training due to his accent resulting in more work for the support staff. Part of his job required him to dictate information via a telephone line and his secretarial team were not able to understand what he was saying. This resulted in errors; more time being spent on his documents and unhappy clients. Clients also had difficulty communicating with him by telephone. The company valued him very highly and were aware that this had become a major issue and was affecting the business. Through training the gentleman learnt how to dictate more effectively; slowing down his speech and being more precise with his diction. He maintained his accent, but was able to modify it for workcase situations.

In the other instance, we worked with an inspirational team of estate agents based in the North East. Their warm, friendly approach to clients - many of whom were based in the South East or who were foreign, was seen as over familiar for a client/supplier relationship. Clients also found it quite difficult to understand the team on the phone and often there were 'unprofessional' conversations in the office that were clearly audible in the background when clients were on the phone or in the office. Whilst not wishing to dampen the natural positive characteristics of the team, we made them aware of professional and private behaviour, relationships and conversations. We also focused on how to modify the voice with clearer diction on the telephone, so that clients were able to understand more easily. Again, there was a marked increase in sales once the training was implemented.

If we regard Michel Roux's Service, all of the trainees had accents: yes, RP is an accent. They all modified how they spoke; what they said; their behaviour and body language to work in a Five Star environment. Their accents weren't an issue as it was the overall package that counted.

So here are the top tips for ensuring you are employable, whatever your accent is:

• Speak clearly and if necessary slow down your speech to ensure people understand you.
• On the telephone, take special care to listen and speak very clearly.
• Develop rapport with good eye contact and positive, open body language.
• Check the environment you are going to work in; is it an environment you are familiar with or wish to work in? If not, look for another opportunity.

http://www.executivevoice.co.uk

Why we must treasure our regional accents -Times Online

Further to my last blog, I've had a response. Yes; other people agree that grammatical errors devalue the speaker's message; their trustworthiness and unfortunately their intelligence. One reader mentioned the habit of inflections at the end of phrases, so that every sentence sounds like a question. "I'm going to the gym" - with an upward inflection. Also the "I went to the shops, and it was, like, SOO busy." - complete with rolling eyes and flicky hair.

I've come across another article promoting regional accents.
Why we must treasure our regional accents -Times Online

My message is still to treasure regional variety, but to be aware of your use of grammar; speak clearly and don't go up at the end of every sentence unless it's a question!!

Regional accents thrive against the odds in Britain - Times Online

I am a great fan of regional accents: well some; I have difficulty with the Estuary glottal stop and some Scouse accents, for the reason I am unable to understand them. Regional accents and a variety in the way we speak is music to the ears. I was therefore delighted to read the following article.

Regional accents thrive against the odds in Britain - Times Online

My only comment is to keep speaking in a regional accent. However, remember your grammar. Remember Alesha Dixon as a judge. She had a strong Southern accent, but it was her lack of basic grammar that annoyed people, and devalued what she said.

More information from http://www.executivevoice.co.uk