Wednesday 25 May 2011

The Art of Bragging - Adopt The Apprentice style

As you know, I am a great fan of The Apprentice: it is great entertainment, and I spend a great deal of the programme laughing and cringing. I know that the contestants are exhausted and stressed, and that the programmes are very cleverly edited, however, some of the contestants' comments are risible! Of course it takes a particular person to even apply for such a show. I came across the link below, from the BBC, which highlights the communication style of some of the contestants.


Of course it is difficult to judge how much to 'brag' - particularly when you are in a contest with other people. There has to be an element of self promotion within any business situation. Whilst we could ask for referrals, there is nothing like 'selling ourselves' or our services. BUT, as seen on The Apprentice, there is a balance, and showing off, or making ridiculous comments, only backfire.

Marketing of celebrities and musicians, is a particularly dangerous area; I am sure I am more cynical because I know an awful lot about this industry, but claims of "The world's best voice", "The most beautiful voice in the world", "You are another Nina Simone - that good", "The best singer song writer the world has ever seen". The problem with these comments are that a creative PR company or X Factor judge has put out a comment about their client. Before we know it, this is quoted as true for that artiste. The artiste has a long way to fall, and in some cases starts to believe the hype.

TV companies that are wanting to publicise an underperforming show "The popular show", "The rating winning show", "The cutting edge, cult show" - even though these programmes have 10% viewing on prime time TV and their viewing numbers are beaten by repeat daytime shows.

Another comment I've recently read "Possibly the best ********** winner we've ever had". - either he is the best or he isn't.

I wonder if individuals are mixing a dream or vision with reality. It is perfectly okay to dream that you are going to set up and run a business, with ultimately a £1M annual turnover. But to say "I'm running a global organisation with a £1M turnover", when you are in startup and the only part of your global empire is your website.

So my tip is: self promote - yes, but always be able to back up what you say with evidence!!!

Good luck.




Thursday 19 May 2011

Where did you get that hat?

The Apprentice on BBC1, continued to entertain last night with another jaw dropping edition. Of course we have to acknowledge the editors in picking the most amusing scenes from many hours of film. However, from a communication perspective, there are a number of priceless scenes!

  • A contestant cold calling a rival hotel's procurement (The Ritz) to ask for a copy of their suppliers' list. Karren's face was a picture. The contestant had no idea about building up a business relationship based on trust: let's face it a cold call: asking for The Ritz's invaluable resource that they'd built up over a number of years. Dur!
  • The cloche saga; they didn't even know how to pronounce it, let alone know what it was. Yes: there are cloches that are used for gardening, but surely they could work out that a hotel wouldn't need 'garden' cloches.
  • The upward negotiation gag; one contestant started with a low price: each time she negotiated with the vendor, she quoted a higher price. I thought negotiation involved trying to get the lowest price: not the highest!
  • The lurking presence of a moustached man, whenever a female was on the phone; he barked orders, so she was having two conversations: with the company and him. He even grabbed the phone, mid-conversation, to complete a call. What a negative advert for anyone that was considering working with him.
  • The total lack of time spent assessing the nature of the business; those posh, Mayfair shops are quite intimidating at the best of time: unless you are a young successful business person apparently. They just marched into these shops, expecting to negotiate a 'deal' with a huge sense of entitlement. 'They wouldn't even knock 1p off the price" said one contestant. Why do they have to? The King of Tonga pays full price: if the BBC broadcast a company giving even 1p off, their client base would all be on the phone asking for a refund! I presume no prices were displayed; don't they know the saying that if you need to know the price, you can't afford it?
  • The hilarious "I have a very important client" comment by Susan, topped by the vendor's "What's that to me". The apprentices made the mistake of believing that they could get anything for the price they wanted. They had a total sense of entitlement and a disregard for the vendor's costs and overheads. 
  • The genuine shock and horror faces, when prices were quoted. OMG was said more than once. My husband told me that you try not to give anything away with your body language and what you say, because it weakens your position with negotiating. Has anyone told Susan that?
  • Listening; it appeared that they weren't listening to the vendors but just waiting to quote another price. How not to create rapport in one easy lesson.
If we contrast with the wonderful Irish charmer with the sad eyes. He engaged the vendors, and developed a fast rapport. In the butchers, he managed to get another £10 off and a hug from another vendor. His manner was open, friendly and not arrogant.

I am sure they are very tired (they always get up really early and people have told me they are exhausted), BUT why are these basic mistakes made by, well, some of the most successful young business people in the country. Ha! 

Monday 16 May 2011

The Apprentice Braggers

I am a great fan of The Apprentice, and certainly I will be blogging and podcasting about this entertaining show in the next few weeks. Yes; I say entertaining, because with good editing and casting, the BBC are able to create a show rather than a basic business programme.

I am always astonished by the 'bragging': the mission statements and straplines some of the contestants utter. I know they will have been interviewed for hours and the producer cleverly picks one off the cuff remark. Perhaps I was brought up to be modest, and this is, of course, in a contest, a problem, but some of the statements from contestants is...well....

One of the most memorable comments is from a female who has been 'taught' by The Dalai Lama and Al Gore and has worked on projects with 12 Nobel Peace Prize winners. And how old is she? I'd love to know which school she went to. Perhaps the truth is slightly embroidered; reading books 'teaches' you about a person's values and thoughts. The trouble is that over inflated boasts often put you into a weak position, since others start to joke about you. It is the case of the shepherd boy who cries 'Wolf' one too many times: no one takes you seriously so when you are truthful, you've already lost their trust.
I know we all have to blow our trumpet, and for individuals that are quieter and more modest by nature, this is more of a challenge, but their needs to be a reality check and a balance. My challenge to you, is to start boasting, and when a trusted colleague or friend starts squealing, or accuses you of arrogance, you will know how far is acceptable!!